Shopping for a new front door can feel overwhelming with so many options out there. Fiberglass, steel, and wood each have their strengths, but how do you know which is right for your home? The truth is, the best exterior door isn’t the same for everyone. It’s the one that balances durability, energy efficiency, and style in a way that fits your home and lifestyle.
The tricky part? There isn’t one material that fits all. What’s considered the “best” material depends on your climate, lifestyle, and design preferences. Let’s take a look at the most popular exterior door materials so you can find the perfect fit for your home.
Table of Contents
Exterior Door Material Types
When it comes to choosing the right front door material for your home, there are several options to consider. Each type of material has its unique benefits and drawbacks, depending on your preferences, budget, and the climate in your area. Here are some of the most common materials used for front doors:
- Fiberglass
- Steel
- Wood
- Aluminum
Why Your Exterior Door Material Matters
Your front door does more than open and close. It works hard every day to protect your home, welcome guests, and add style to your curb appeal. The material you choose plays a big role in how well your door performs in terms of:
- Durability: A durable door that is resistant to dents, scratches, and daily wear reduces repairs and extends its lifespan.
- Energy efficiency: A properly sealed door keeps outdoor air where it belongs, helping your home remain comfortable year-round.
- Security: A solid, well-constructed door can provide greater peace of mind by adding an additional layer of protection for your family.
- Maintenance: Some doors require seasonal care, while others only need a quick wipe-down to stay looking like new.
- Curb appeal: The right door makes a strong first impression and beautifully complements your home’s overall architecture.
A new door is an investment you’ll see and use every day, which makes choosing the right material worth the extra thought.
What’s the Best Material For An Entry Door?
Fiberglass Doors for Durability and Low Maintenance
Fiberglass has become a go-to choice for homeowners who want long-lasting performance without needing a ton of upkeep. These doors are designed to handle heavy use and unpredictable, extreme weather while still offering plenty of style options.
Key advantages of fiberglass include:
- Durability: Resists dents, rust, and warping.
- Energy Efficiency: Excellent insulation for year-round savings.
- Style Flexibility: Mimics real wood with realistic grain finishes.
- All-weather Performance: Performs well in hot summers and freezing winters.
Possible drawbacks:
- Upfront Cost: Typically higher than steel.
- Aesthetic Feel: Lacks the natural luxury of solid wood.
For many households, it’s a choice between style and strength. Fiberglass gives you the best of both worlds: strength and beauty with minimum maintenance. If you’re considering entry doors that balance efficiency with style, fiberglass is one of the most reliable options available today.
Steel Doors for Strength and Security
If security is your top priority, steel is often the first material that comes to mind. These doors are known for their unmatched strength and are one of the most budget-friendly options for homeowners.
Key advantages of steel doors include:
- Strength: Steel provides maximum protection against forced entry.
- Affordability: Less expensive upfront than fiberglass or solid wood.
- Fire Resistance: Many models offer a higher fire rating for added safety.
- Climate Control: Properly insulated steel doors reduce drafts and improve comfort.
Possible drawbacks:
- Easily Dented and Scratched: Unlike fiberglass, surface damage is more noticeable.
- Temperature Transfer: Can feel hot or cold to the touch depending on the weather.
- Limited Design Options: Fewer customization choices compared to wood.
For homeowners who want reliable security without stretching their budget, steel doors remain a practical and trusted option.
They’re also an excellent choice for side entry or storm doors where strength matters most.
Wood Doors for Timeless Beauty
Nothing matches the warmth and character of a solid wood door. For centuries, wood has been the classic choice, offering a natural look that never goes out of style.
Key advantages of wood doors include:
- Aesthetic Appeal: Rich textures and grains create a welcoming entryway.
- Customization: Can be carved, stained, or painted to fit your style.
- Variety: Available in multiple species, from oak to mahogany.
- Classic Feel: Adds value and elegance to traditional and modern homes alike.
Possible drawbacks:
- Maintenance required: Needs regular sealing or painting to prevent warping or cracking.
- Weather sensitivity: Less ideal in extreme climates without protection like a porch or awning.
- Cost: High-quality wood doors are typically more expensive.
Wood doors are often chosen for their charm and customization potential. They pair well with homes where design and craftsmanship matter most, but we do not recommend them for the Midwest climate since they are prone to rotting and warping.
If you want the warmth and look of wood without the upkeep, fiberglass is the best alternative for front door styles. Browsing an entry door inspiration gallery for visual inspiration can help you find the perfect match.
Comparing the Most Popular Exterior Door Materials
With so many options, it helps to see how the top three materials stack up side by side.
| Material | Pros | Cons | Best Fit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fiberglass | Durable, low-maintenance, energy-efficient, wood-look designs | Higher upfront cost | Homes in variable climates need efficiency and style |
| Steel | Strongest for security, budget-friendly, fire-rated | Dents easily, limited design choices | Storm/security doors or cost-conscious upgrades |
| Wood | Classic look, customizable, wide variety | High maintenance, weather-sensitive, expensive | Homes with covered entryways and design-focused buyers |
When deciding, also consider your front door size, as a proper fit is just as important as the material itself. An ill-fitting door can lead to drafts, higher energy bills, and even security issues over time. Making sure your new door is sized and installed correctly gives us the full benefits of its durability, efficiency, and style.
Fiberglass vs. Wood vs. Steel material for exterior doors infographic
What is the Best Exterior Door Material for Midwest Homes?
Living in the Midwest means dealing with just about everything, from humid, sweltering summers to icy winters and sudden storms. In the face of these extremes, your door material should be built to handle temperature swings, humidity spikes, and heavy use.
Fiberglass is often the best long-term choice, since it resists rotting and warping, offers excellent insulation, and can withstand both heat and cold. It keeps energy bills more predictable and holds up well to years of wear.
Steel also performs well, particularly as a storm or security door. It provides unmatched protection, though dents from hail or heavy use can be more noticeable over time.
The beauty of wood doors is timeless, no doubt—but that classic look can weather quickly in the Midwest without the cover of a porch or awning. Without that extra coverage, moisture and temperature changes may lead to swelling, cracking, or fading over time. In some cases, wood doors can begin rotting and even grow mold when exposed to too much water.
For most Midwest households, fiberglass offers the strongest balance of durability, insulation, and style. Still, your personal preference is the final deciding point that determines which door feels like the best fit.
Need Help? Our Team Provides Entry Door Replacement Services to Homes in Downers Grove, Orland Park, St. Charles, Madison, & Other Areas
Bonus Tips on Frames and Installation
A door is only as good as its frame. High-quality frames prevent drafts, support security, and keep your door performing well over the years. Materials like composite or vinyl are often a smarter investment than basic wood, since they resist rot and warping far better in changing weather.
Professional installation is just as important. A properly installed door will close smoothly, seal tightly, and keep your home comfortable no matter the season. Beyond comfort, expert installation extends the life of your door and ensures it looks and functions the way it should—saving you from frustrating repairs down the road.
FAQs About Exterior Door Materials
Which exterior door lasts the longest?
Fiberglass doors are known for their durability and often last decades with very little maintenance. They don’t warp, rust, or crack easily, making them ideal for homes in climates with extreme temperature swings.
What is the most secure front door?
Steel doors are widely considered the strongest option when security is your top priority. Their solid construction makes them harder to force open, and many models also come with reinforced locks or higher fire ratings.
Are wood doors worth the maintenance?
For many homeowners, wood doors are worth the extra care thanks to their timeless charm and customization options. They can be stained, carved, or painted to create a unique entryway. Just be prepared to seal and maintain them regularly if you want them to stay strong against the elements.
Ready to Upgrade Your Exterior Door?
Your front door sets the tone every time you come and go. It welcomes friends and family, protects what matters most, and adds to your home’s unique aesthetic. Fiberglass and steel each offer unique benefits, and the best choice will be the one that fits your lifestyle, complements your home, and stands up to the Midwest climate.
At NEXT Door & Window, our team can help you compare options, walk you through designs, and ensure your door is installed to last. Explore our selection of entry doors and browse entry door inspiration to start imagining the perfect look for your home.
Schedule your free virtual consultation today and take the first step toward a stronger, more beautiful entryway.
Additional Resources for Entry Doors:
Comments are closed.
